There is no single price that fits every Twin Cities roof. A useful replacement estimate starts with measured roof area, the condition of the existing roof, the materials selected and a clearly defined scope—not just the size of the house or an online average.
This guide explains the questions that help you compare proposals. It does not publish a Foremost price range or quote for your property.
A roofing square means 100 square feet of roof surface. The measurement is for the roof itself, not interior living space. Pitch, overhangs, attached garages and the shape of the roof can make the two very different. Malarkey’s roofing warranty glossary uses the same square measurement.
Ask whether the estimate separates measured area from additional material allowed for cuts and layout. Materials ordered are not automatically the same as the roof’s measured area.
A straightforward roof and a roof with multiple valleys, dormers, chimneys or skylights involve different details. Height, slope, access for materials and debris, and protection of the surrounding property also affect the work being priced.
The proposal should state what will be removed and how disposal is handled. Ask whether the price assumes a particular number of existing layers and what happens if conditions differ once work begins.
Some conditions cannot be fully evaluated until roofing is removed. Ask how damaged decking or other concealed conditions will be documented, priced and authorized. A proposal can explain its allowance or unit-pricing method without pretending the amount of hidden damage is already known.
Compare the exact shingle product and the supporting system: underlayment, ice-and-water protection, starter, ridge components, flashing and ventilation work. Different proposals may include different components or different amounts of detail work. Ask which manufacturer instructions and applicable local requirements inform the scope.
Have the proposal explain the treatment of chimneys, walls, plumbing vents, skylights and other transitions. “Roof replacement” alone does not tell you which existing parts will be reused, repaired or replaced.
Manufacturer product coverage and contractor workmanship coverage are different. Enhanced manufacturer programs may require specific components, installation conditions, an eligible contractor and registration. Compare the actual documents, not just a headline such as “lifetime.” Owens Corning explains the main warranty categories; Malarkey describes its standard and enhanced options.
Before choosing between prices, look for these details in each written proposal:
Scroll table horizontally to compare details
| Item | What to check |
|---|---|
| Measurements | Roof area, measurement source and separately identified ordering allowance |
| Removal | Existing materials/layers included and disposal plan |
| Decking | Inspection approach, pricing method and authorization for additional work |
| Materials | Shingle manufacturer, exact product, color and supporting components |
| Water-management details | Specified underlayment, ice-and-water protection, flashing and penetration work |
| Ventilation | What is being evaluated, retained or changed |
| Permits and inspections | Who verifies requirements, obtains any required permit and coordinates inspections |
| Property protection | Staging, landscaping protection, debris handling and cleanup |
| Warranties | Named manufacturer coverage, contractor coverage, exclusions and registration responsibility |
| Price and payment | Included work, exclusions, allowances, payment schedule and change-order process |
A lower price is not automatically a poor proposal, and a higher price is not automatically better. First identify the differences in scope and ask for explanations.
Illustrative, anonymized example from an actual Foremost residential proposal. The scope descriptions below are condensed. Prices, personal details, property information and claim information have been removed. This compares options within one proposal, not bids from different contractors, and is not a current quote or standard scope for every project.
The proposal offered two package choices with the same roofing work but different treatment of the garage gutters. It also separated optional roof-component upgrades from work that still needed pricing.
| Item in the proposal | How it was separated | What to check in your estimates |
|---|---|---|
| Roofing shared by both packages | The same roof work appeared in each package. The homeowner was to choose one package, not combine both totals. | Which work stays the same when you compare options? |
| Existing garage gutters versus new gutters | One package included detaching and resetting the existing gutters. The alternative replaced that line with removal and a new gutter system. | Does the revised total remove the work being replaced, or does it add the entire new option on top? |
| Pipe flashing | Standard pipe flashings were already included. A separately listed pipe-boot upgrade changed the component being installed. | Is an upgrade price the additional cost above the included component, or a full replacement price? Ask for that distinction in writing. |
| Attic exhaust ventilation | A turbine-vent option was listed separately. The proposal called for checking attic area, exhaust requirements, available intake and the final layout before installation. | Does the ventilation scope address intake as well as exhaust? Are any needed intake improvements included or separately priced? |
| Additional decking and permit items | These were identified for separate pricing before authorization. | What remains unpriced, and how will its quantity, price and approval be documented? |
A fixed scope identifies the work covered by the stated price. An allowance sets aside an amount or quantity for a particular item; ask what it covers and how differences will be handled. An item marked for separate pricing has not become a priced allowance merely because it appears in the proposal.
In this example, the gutter alternative explicitly replaced the existing detach-and-reset line. Additional decking was left for separate pricing. Those are different situations and should not be treated as interchangeable entries when comparing totals.
Before approving additional work, ask for photos of the condition, the proposed repair, the quantity and material, the price or agreed unit-rate calculation, and any effect on the schedule. Have the written update distinguish new work from work already included.
These are questions to ask about a possible change. This example does not establish that hidden damage was found, a particular quantity of decking was replaced, or a change order was completed.
A different pipe boot or vent does not, by itself, establish different coverage for the whole roof. Compare the named product warranty, any enhanced manufacturer program, and the contractor's workmanship terms separately. Ask which components, eligibility conditions and registration steps apply to the coverage being offered. Manufacturer warranty programs can have different requirements and coverage.
The useful comparison is the selected work, the remaining unknowns and the written terms, not just the total at the bottom of each option.
A contractor’s estimate and an insurer’s coverage decision answer different questions. The estimate describes work and pricing; your insurer explains coverage, deductibles, depreciation and any conditions for payment under your policy.
Do not assume an approved claim pays for every optional upgrade or that a new roof guarantees a premium reduction. Ask your insurer about your specific property, policy and proposed product before relying on a particular reimbursement or discount.
For a hail concern, Foremost’s free hail inspection includes a visual review, photos and next-step guidance. Any formal report or additional service is confirmed separately. Learn about hail inspections.
Interior square footage alone is not enough for an accurate roof proposal. Roof measurements and the planned work matter. Photos or existing measurements may help start the conversation, but the scope still needs to be confirmed.
No. A per-square price is only useful when you also understand the included materials, removal, details, allowances and other charges. Compare the scope before comparing the unit price.
There is no fixed upgrade amount stated here. Ask for the exact products to be compared on the same roof and understand any differences in supporting components or warranty options.
Not necessarily. A lower total may reflect a different scope, materials or allowances. Ask what is included and excluded instead of assuming the proposals are identical.
Check the proposal. It should explain what the base price includes and how additional decking work would be handled if needed. Do not treat an unknown quantity as a confirmed cost.
Ask for a project-specific schedule that considers roof size, details, material availability, access and weather. A general online timeframe is not a reserved installation date.
Confirm requirements for the property’s jurisdiction and the particular scope. The proposal should make responsibility for permits and inspections clear. For the code side, see our Minnesota roofing code and permit checklist.
Tell us the property location, what you are noticing and whether you are considering a repair or replacement. We can discuss the appropriate next step and clarify the proposed scope before you decide.
Contact Foremost Exteriors or call (952) 495-5545.